Vanilla, a precious and misunderstood spice

Vanilla. A word that immediately brings to mind sweetness, comfort, and indulgence. Yet behind its simple reputation lies one of the most complex and labor-intensive spices in the world. Vanilla is not just a flavor—it’s an ingredient that demands respect, precision, and care.

In both savory and sweet cooking, using vanilla properly can make all the difference. As Joël Robuchon once said, a single vanilla pod can be used three times if you know how to handle it. But before you can master it, you need to understand it – from how to choose the right pod to the many ways to use it without waste.

In this article, we’ll explore the world of vanilla in depth: its origins, its varieties, how to identify quality, how to extract its full potential, and how to avoid the artificial shortcuts that compromise its integrity. By the end, you’ll be able to use every last speck of vanilla with the confidence of a chef.

The origins and varieties of vanilla

Vanilla comes from the pod of a tropical orchid, Vanilla planifolia, native to Mexico. For centuries, it was cultivated and used by the Totonac people, then adopted by the Aztecs, who famously combined it with cacao. The Spanish brought vanilla to Europe in the 16th century, but it wasn’t until the 19th century that the plant could be successfully pollinated outside its native region.

The key breakthrough came in 1841, when a 12-year-old enslaved boy on Réunion Island discovered how to hand-pollinate the orchid – an essential technique still used today. Without manual pollination, the plant cannot produce fruit, making vanilla one of the most labor-intensive spices in the world. Pods take 8–9 months to mature. The pictures bellow show the pollination of the Tahitian Vanilla (Vanilla tahitensis) which has a slightly different floral anatomy than Vanilla planifolia. Shout-out to Mareva @ Manutea Vanille, French Polynesia.

Today, most of the world’s vanilla is produced in the Indian Ocean region, particularly in Madagascar, which accounts for around 80% of global production. But depending on the origin, each variety of vanilla offers a distinct aromatic profile. For instance, Tahitian vanilla pods are renowned for their captivating floral notes, as well as their subtle scents of anise and prunes. It’s hard to find better in terms of flavor and quality. The best choice though always depends on your specific needs, how you plan to use it and your budget. 

  • Bourbon vanilla, grown in Madagascar, Réunion, and the Comoros, is the most common. It has a rich, sweet, and creamy profile with warm notes of cocoa and dried fruit.
  • Tahitian vanilla, which comes from Vanilla tahitensis, has a floral, fruity aroma with hints of anise. It is softer and more delicate, making it ideal for cold infusions and exotic desserts.
  • Mexican vanilla is often more spicy and woody, with subtle smokiness. It carries the original terroir of the vanilla orchid.

Like wine or coffee, the flavor of vanilla reflects the soil, climate, and craftsmanship of its region. Understanding these differences allows you to choose the right vanilla for the right dish.

How to choose a quality vanilla pod?

Not all vanilla is created equal. A high-quality vanilla bean should be judged first by appearance, then by aroma. When you hold a good vanilla pod in your hands, you should feel its flexibility. It should be plump, slightly oily, and supple, not brittle or dry. In average, a vanilla bean weighs 5-6 grams. Tahitian pods look often plumper than other varieties ≈ 8-10 grams each. According to Mareva, the biggest vanilla pod size found was 20 grams of weight!

vanilla-bunches

A fresh vanilla pod will have a deep brown to black color and a natural gloss on the surface. If it cracks when bent or looks dull and shriveled, it has likely been dried out too much or stored improperly. You should also avoid beans that have visible mold or smell musty instead of sweet and fragrant.

The aroma is perhaps the most revealing element. Real vanilla has an unmistakable, complex perfume that’s floral, creamy, and earthy all at once. It should never smell alcoholic, acidic, or overly sweet—those are signs of artificial flavoring or poor quality control.

When buying vanilla, it’s best to source from trusted suppliers who specialize in natural products. Purchase them sous-vide. Single-origin beans from small producers often offer better traceability and higher quality than mass-market vanilla sold in supermarkets which are too often small and dry.

Choosing quality vanilla is an investment. It may be more expensive upfront, but when used properly, one pod can flavor several preparations—and elevate every single one of them.

How to use a vanilla bean – the three lives of a pod

One of the most beautiful things about a vanilla pod is how much it can give – if you know how to treat it right. As Joël Robuchon famously said, a single bean can be used three times. Each use brings out different layers of its aroma, allowing you to make the most of this precious ingredient without waste.

The first and most intense use is, of course, when the pod is fresh. Start by placing the pod flat on a cutting board. With a sharp paring knife, slice it lengthwise, from top to bottom, to open it like a book. Inside, you’ll find a sticky, black paste filled with thousands of tiny seeds. These are the famous vanilla “caviar.”

Scrape the seeds out gently and add them to warm liquids – cream, milk, or syrup – along with the whole pod. Both the seeds and the pod are full of flavor and should always be used together. Infuse the mixture hot or cold for up to 48 hours for best results.

After the first infusion, don’t throw the pod away. Rinse it under water, pat it dry, and let it air-dry completely or in warm oven. Once it’s dry, you can use it again to flavor a lighter preparation – perhaps a fruit compote, a syrup for cocktails, or a batch of rice pudding. The aroma will be subtler, but still meaningful.

Finally, once the pod has been used and dried a second time, it still has one last gift to give: it can be turned into homemade vanilla sugar. Simply blend the dry pod with sugar in a food processor, then sift the mixture to create a fine, fragrant powder. Stored in an airtight jar, it keeps for years and is perfect for doughs, cookies, cakes, or even your morning coffee, mocha etc…

Using a vanilla pod to its full potential isn’t just economical – it’s a way of honoring the incredible work that goes into producing it.

Understanding the different forms of vanilla

While the whole vanilla bean is the purest and most aromatic form, it’s not always the most practical option. In everyday cooking and baking, many turn to other formats. Some of which are excellent, others far less convincing. Knowing the difference is essential if you want to preserve the integrity of your recipes.

Vanilla powder is made from whole beans that have been dried and finely ”cold” ground. It is extremely concentrated, with no added sugar or liquid, making it perfect for everything. It worth noting that about 0.5 gram of vanilla powder equal one vanilla bean.

Vanilla sugar is a more common format, but it varies greatly in quality. Industrial vanilla sugar is often artificially flavored and contains little to no real vanilla. Homemade vanilla sugar, made by grinding used pods into fine sugar, is a more fragrant and authentic alternative. It can also be made by simply storing dry pods in a jar of sugar for several weeks.

Then there are the extracts (perhaps the most misunderstood category). A true vanilla extract is made by macerating whole vanilla beans in a solution of alcohol over several months. It’s rich, natural, and layered, and should be labeled as “pure vanilla extract” or “natural vanilla extract.”

In contrast, imitation vanilla or vanillin is often produced synthetically, sometimes from wood pulp, caramel, sometimes even from petrochemical byproducts or worse from the anal glands of beavers… All fake vanilla may smell like vanilla, but it lacks depth and leaves an artificial aftertaste. Unfortunately, it’s widely used in processed foods and cheaper products.

When choosing an extract or paste, always check the label. A quality extract will list only vanilla used in high percentage. Some vanilla extracts or paste may contain sweetener and thickener which are not necessarily a turn off but if you see vague terms like “flavor” or “aroma,” it’s likely not the real thing. Thick, dark and pure vanilla paste is something else; 3 grams of pure vanilla paste equal one bean.

Each form of vanilla has its purpose. Whole pods for infusion, powder for everything and dry preparations, sugar for doughs, and extract for convenience but doughs. The key is choosing the right one for the right use – and never compromising on quality.

How to use vanilla properly in cooking and baking?

Fabulous Vanilla Yule Log
An explosion of flavor
Check out this recipe
Bruno Albouze Vanilla Yule Log
Vanilla Ice Cream
Make it right!
Check out this recipe
Bruno Albouze Vanilla Ice Cream
Vanilla Raspberry Crown
Wow!
Check out this recipe
vanilla raspberry bubble crown
Vanilla Risotto Soufflé
Incredible 😋
Check out this recipe
Bruno Albouze Vanilla Risotto Soufflé
Vanilla Custard Apple Pie
Taste first
Check out this recipe
Bruno Albouze Vanilla Custard Apple Pie
Macarons
Vanilla’s delicate, aromatic note perfectly complements the rich, caramelized sweetness of dulce de leche!
Check out this recipe
Floating Island
A sweet classic
Check out this recipe
Bruno Albouze Floating Islands

Vanilla may seem like a simple flavor, but using it well requires subtlety and technique. Whether you’re making a custard, a cake, or even a savory sauce, understanding how to handle vanilla can elevate your dish from ordinary to exceptional.

When using whole pods, always infuse them gently. Heat your milk, cream, or syrup to a simmer, then remove from the heat and let the vanilla steep slowly. Or, infuse in a cold liquid for up to 48 hours.

For recipes that don’t involve liquids, such as doughs or dry mixes, vanilla powder or homemade vanilla sugar is often the better option. These formats integrate easily and evenly, without altering the texture or hydration of the preparation.

Vanilla pairs well with dairy, eggs, nuts, milk and white chocolate, and many fruits, especially apple, stone fruits and berries. It’s also a natural enhancer, it deepens other flavors, making them more complex and balanced. That’s why a little vanilla in a Chantilly or a caramel sauce makes all the difference.

You don’t need much. One good vanilla pod is usually enough for 1 liter of liquid or a medium-sized dessert recipe. If you’re using extract, a teaspoon is often sufficient, but again, it depends on the quality. Powder and paste will do the job too!

It’s worth noting that vanilla also works in savory dishes, particularly those involving seafood or shellfish. A touch of vanilla in a butter sauce for lobster or scallops can create a surprisingly elegant result. It also blends beautifully with risotto, mashed potatoes, sweet potato, pumpkin, and certain spice blends.

Vanilla isn’t just a flavor, it’s a structure, a background note that brings harmony to a dish. Used properly, it should never dominate, but rather support and enhance everything around it.

Vanilla is much more than a background flavor. It is one of the most complex and labor-intensive ingredients in the kitchen, requiring months of cultivation, hand-pollination, curing, and care before it even reaches your hands.

Using it thoughtfully, extracting every drop of aroma, repurposing the pod, choosing quality over shortcuts, is a way of honoring the people and traditions behind it. When you handle vanilla with care, you’re not only improving your cooking, you’re also respecting the craft that brought it to life.

One pod, three lives. A flavor, a story, a legacy.

Scroll to Top